
Welcome to the FIG Top 5 at 5
The Top 5 at 5 is a weekly update in which members of the Financial Institutions Group (FIG) identify five of the key legal and regulatory developments relevant to the financial services industry from the preceding week.
Priority is given, in the first instance, to Irish based developments but the update will also include important developments in European law and regulation.
The topics chosen are dictated by the developments during the relevant period but priority is given to cross sectoral developments. The FIG Top 5 at 5 is not intended to represent all developments of note for the relevant period but rather a snap shot of some of the issues which we feel are of particular importance.
Should you have any queries in respect of the contents of the update, please do not hesitate to contact your usual Matheson LLP contact or any member of our team detailed below.
The Top 5 at 5
On 16 November 2026, the Department of Finance (“Department”) published a press release (“Press Release”) announcing that Tánaiste and Minister for Finance, Simon Harris, would sign new regulations giving legal effect in Ireland to the revised Consumer Credit Directive.
Accordingly, the European Union (Consumer Credit Agreements) Regulations 2026 (“Regulations”) were published on 18 November 2026.
The Regulations confirm that the new rules will come into operation on 20 November 2026.
The Press Release states that the new rules strengthen consumer protection and modernise the regulatory framework to reflect developments in the consumer credit market, including new credit products and digitalisation.
Key provisions
Some of the key provisions highlighted in the Press Release are as follows:
- pre-contractual information – lenders will be required to provide clearer information before consumers enter into credit agreements, enabling more informed borrowing decisions;
- wider product coverage – the rules will cover a broader range of credit products, including loans below €200, credit agreements up to €100,000 and additional types of lending, such as buy-now-pay-later;
- affordability and creditworthiness assessments – enhanced assessments are intended to prevent irresponsible lending and reduce the risk of consumer over-indebtedness;
- withdrawal rights – a right to withdraw without giving a reason, generally within 14 calendar days of concluding the credit from credit agreement or, if later, receiving the contractual terms and required information; and
- automated creditworthiness assessments – consumers will have rights to explanations, human intervention and review where automated processing is used in assessing creditworthiness.
Published Regulations
In addition to the protections highlighted above, the published Regulations provide for:
- advertising and sales practices – credit advertising must be fair, clear and not misleading and carry a prominent warning about the cost of borrowing. The Regulations also prohibit unsolicited granting of credit and reliance on pre-ticked boxes to establish consumer agreement;
- consumers in financial difficulty – creditors must have policies and processes for early detection of financial difficulties, refer affected consumers to debt advisory services and, where appropriate, exercise reasonable forbearance before initiating enforcement proceedings;
- conduct and staff requirements – creditors and credit intermediaries must act honestly, fairly, transparently and professionally, with requirements covering staff knowledge and competence and remuneration arrangements; and
- scope and exclusions – the Regulations contain specific exclusions, including for certain supplier-provided deferred payment arrangements, and extend to unsecured credit above €100,000 where it is for the renovation of residential property.
Supervision
The Regulations confirm that the Central Bank of Ireland (“Central Bank”) is the competent authority for creditors, while the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission is the competent authority for credit intermediaries.
The Regulations will complement the existing consumer protection provisions in the Consumer Credit Act and the Central Bank’s Consumer Protection Code.
Next steps
The Regulations come into operation on 20 November 2026 and replace the European Communities (Consumer Credit Agreements) Regulations 2010. The 2010 regime will generally continue to apply to existing credit agreements until their termination, although specified provisions of the new Regulations will apply to existing open-end credit agreements.
1. Central Bank publishes consultation on amendments to list of pre-approval controlled functions
On 17 November 2026, the Central Bank of Ireland (“Central Bank”) published a consultation paper (“CP175”) on proposed amendments to the list of pre-approval controlled functions (“PCFs”) set out in Schedule 2 of the Central Bank Reform Act 2010 (Sections 20 and 22) Regulations 2011, as amended (“F&P Regulations”).
The Central Bank sets out that the proposals would reduce the number of PCF roles by 60%, reducing applications for pre-approval by approximately 420, or 12%, annually.
Reason for the consultation
CP175 comes on foot of the recommendation in Andrea Enria’s independent review of the fitness and probity (“F&P”) regime that the Central Bank review the number of roles designated as PCFs – for more information, see FIG Top 5 at 5 dated 18 July 2024. It also advances the Central Bank’s December 2025 commitment to review the PCF list to reduce the administrative burden for firms while maintaining clarity regarding responsibilities – for more information, see FIG Top 5 at 5 dated FIG Top 5 at 5 dated 11 December 2025.
The proposed reform aims to simplify the PCF framework, placing greater responsibility on firms to ensure executives meet the Central Bank’s F&P standards while retaining regulatory oversight of the most critical roles.
Key proposed changes
The principal changes proposed by CP175 include:
- a cross-sectoral PCF list – replacing the current sector-by-sector structure with a general list applying across sectors, as appropriate. For example, head of investment (PCF-19) and chief investment officer (PCF-30) would be merged into a generally applicable head of investment / chief investment officer role. The updated head of credit role refers to individuals responsible for the oversight of the provision of credit as a significant business line and will capture roles applicable to the banking and retail credit sectors;
- removal of requirement for separate approval for board sub-committee chairs – removing PCF-4 to PCF-7, covering the chairs of the audit, risk, remuneration and nomination committees, on the basis that these individuals will already have been approved as board members. The prescribed responsibilities relating to chairing board sub-committees remain applicable for firms in scope of the Senior Executive Accountability Regime (“SEAR”);
- consolidation of safeguarding roles – replacing the existing head of client asset oversight, head of investor money oversight and head of safeguarding PCF roles with one generally applicable head of safeguarding oversight role;
- changes to branch manager roles – removing the existing domestic branch manager roles PCF-28, PCF-32 and PCF-40, which the Central Bank states are no longer utilised. A new PCF role would cover the manager of an Irish branch of an EEA entity approved by the Central Bank to provide depositary or fund administration services;
- removal of overlapping or redundant roles – proposed removals include head of regulation (PCF-26), head of operations (PCF-27), various sector-specific operational roles and the head of material business line roles; and
- changes concerning fund management companies – it is proposed to remove the mandatory requirement to appoint designated persons and removing PCF-39A to PCF-39F from the PCF list. CP175 states that, instead, fund management companies will be required to appoint, at a minimum, a chief executive, chief risk officer and head of investment / chief investment officer. This executive management team requirement will be consulted on separately as part of the Central Bank’s review of the regulatory framework for fund management companies.
No changes are proposed to the PCF lists for credit unions or holding companies. The Central Bank also emphasises that inclusion of a role on the PCF list does not, of itself, require a firm to establish that role. Rather, where the role exists, the pre-approval requirement applies.
Continuing responsibilities for firms
CP175 highlights that the removal of PCF designation does not eliminate regulatory standards. Roles that are no longer designated as PCF roles will remain as controlled function 1 (“CF-1”) roles. Accordingly, removal from the PCF list will remove the requirement for Central Bank pre-approval, but not the firm’s responsibility to ensure the individual’s fitness and probity.
In particular, firms will remain responsible for comprehensive pre-appointment due diligence and annual certification of compliance with the F&P standards. Relevant individuals will remain subject to the common conduct standards and additional conduct standards of the Individual Accountability Framework (“IAF”). For firms in scope of SEAR, management responsibility maps must include reasonable details of CF-1 role holders.
Regulatory impact assessment
In terms of direct impacts on firms, the Central Bank’s regulatory impact assessment (“RIA”) identifies reduced appointment-related costs, greater organisational and succession-planning flexibility, and more focused use of supervisory resources as benefits of the proposals. It concludes that the benefits outweigh the reduction in direct pre-approval oversight, given the continuing obligations on firms and CF-1 role holders and the retention of pre-approval for the most critical roles.
In terms of impacts on consumers, the RIA highlights that the proposed approach in CP175 continues to capture sector-specific roles with responsibility for core activities that have direct implications for consumer outcomes and policyholder protection, ensuring consistency of the level of regulatory oversight across sectors. Additionally, the retention of key control functions, such as risk, compliance, internal audit, and board positions ensure that consumer protection remains embedded in firm governance.
Consultation questions
CP175 seeks feedback on five questions addressing the proposed amendments, any further changes to the PCF list, other F&P-related simplification measures, the RIA, and potential challenges in allocating prescribed responsibilities under SEAR.
Next steps
CP175 is open for feedback until 17 February 2027. Stakeholders wishing to request a bilateral meeting are invited to contact the Central Bank.
The Central Bank anticipates publishing a feedback statement in Q2 2027. Implementation will align with changes arising from the three-year review of the IAF, which will be consulted on separately in Q1 2027, with transitional arrangements provided as appropriate.
The existing F&P and SEAR requirements continue to apply pending implementation. CP175 highlights that the Central Bank intends that the revised PCF list will not affect existing approvals or applications in process for roles retained on the list, and will communicate any related process changes clearly and in advance.
2. Governor of the Central Bank of Ireland delivers speech on foundations for the future of Ireland’s financial system
On 17 November 2026, the Governor of the Central Bank of Ireland (“Central Bank”), Gabriel Makhlouf, delivered a speech entitled “Foundations for the Future: the Central Bank and the Financial System” (“Speech”) at the Federation of International Banks in Ireland. The Speech addressed the role of the Central Bank in supporting a strong and stable international financial centre, progress in enhancing its regulatory and supervisory framework, and technological developments shaping the sector.
Stability, growth and competitiveness
Governor Makhlouf highlighted the growth in Ireland’s international financial services sector, noting that Ireland’s financial system holds more than €11 trillion in assets. He emphasised the importance of Ireland’s economic and political stability, alongside a credible regulatory framework, in underpinning that success.
The Governor cautioned against returning to the practices that contributed to the financial crisis, including ineffective regulation and light-touch supervision. Rather, he described monetary and financial stability, effective payments and settlement systems, and public trust as foundations for sustainable growth and innovation. He also expressed support for the Ireland for Finance Strategy’s (“Strategy”) vision of a financial services hub renowned for “excellence, innovation, and trust”. For more information on the Strategy, see FIG Top 5 at 5 dated 27 August 2026.
Enhancing regulation and supervision
Turning to the Central Bank’s two-year roadmap (“Roadmap”), published in December 2025, the Governor outlined progress in making regulation and supervision more effective, proportionate and easier to navigate. Some of the matters highlighted were as follows:
supervision – integrating supervision across the Central Bank’s mandate, removing outdated requirements and reducing reporting duplication. The Governor highlighted more coordinated engagement with firms and clearer communication of priorities through the Regulatory and Supervisory Outlook Report (“RSO”). For more information on the updated supervisory approach, see FIG Top 5 at 5 dated 4 June 2026 and FIG Top 5 at 5 dated 5 March 2026 for more information on the RSO 2026;
authorisations – bringing authorisation activities for firms, products and individuals together in a new Authorisation Division, alongside investment in technology to streamline processes and improve predictability for applicants;
reporting – reviewing existing requirements and strengthening checks before new information requests are made, so that firms better understand why information is needed and face fewer requests for information available from existing sources;
regulatory quality – introducing frameworks grounded in a new regulatory impact assessment, aimed at better articulating the value of new regulation. For more information on the related consultation, see FIG Top 5 at 5 dated 25 June 2026;
third-party risk – consulting on guidance covering third-party relationships more broadly than the existing outsourcing guidance, which it will replace once finalised. The proposals focus on risk management outcomes and good practices, while seeking to reduce unnecessary administrative burden. For more information, see FIG Top 5 at 5 dated 15 October 2026; and
other initiatives – withdrawing the remaining Impairment Provisions for Credit Exposures and continuing work on the Fund Service Provider Framework, corporate governance and bank customer charge notification processes.
The Governor also announced a consultation on changes to the list of pre-approval controlled functions. CP175 is addressed separately in the update, above.
Maintaining standards
Governor Makhlouf emphasised that reducing burdens will not compromise the resilience and protections built up over the last decade. While the objective for firms is clearer expectations, more coordinated engagement and fewer unnecessary information requests, the framework must remain capable of addressing the sector’s complexity. New rules will be introduced where necessary, but must be well-designed, justified and understood, taking account of the principles of predictability, proportionality and an outcomes-focused approach.
Payments, tokenisation and AI
The Governor identified payments, tokenisation and AI as three potentially significant shifts in financial services delivery. In particular, he highlighted:
payments – central bank money must remain the anchor for wholesale settlement, with Eurosystem projects Pontes and Appia supporting settlement on new platforms in central bank money;
tokenisation – resilience and trust must underpin the system, with interoperability considered from the outset to avoid market fragmentation; and
AI – humans remain accountable for the tools they deploy. The Central Bank plans to deepen its capability to evaluate firms’ AI systems, while its next Innovation Sandbox Programme, focused on AI for consumer good, will open for applications in January 2027.
For more information on the Governor’s recent remarks on AI and tokenisation, including the next Innovation Sandbox Programme, see FIG Top 5 at 5 dated 5 November 2026.
Next steps
The Central Bank will publish a progress report on its Roadmap in December 2026. The Governor described the work as part of a broader strategic shift and commitment to continuous improvement, rather than a standalone programme.
1. Central Bank takes enforcement action for breaches of MAR
On 12 November 2026, the Central Bank of Ireland (“Central Bank”) announced sanctions totalling €67,580 against Mr Alan Dalton, following a settlement reached on 10 November 2026. The accompanying public statement (“Statement”) details two breaches, by Mr Dalton, of article 14(a) of the Market Abuse Regulation (“MAR”), which prohibits insider dealing.
This is the first action taken by the Central Bank against an individual for insider dealing under the European Union (Market Abuse) Regulations 2016 (“2016 Regulations”), and the first occasion on which it has imposed disgorgement as a sanction.
Findings
Mr Dalton was employed by HealthBeacon PLC (“Company”) as contracts manager & head of Ireland between September 2018 and June 2022. He had completed training on his obligations under MAR.
The Statement sets out that:
- through his role, Mr Dalton became aware of specific supply chain issues which meant that the Company would not, in the short term, be able to produce its “Smart Sharps Bin” in the volumes previously advised to investors;
- after ceasing employment on 24 June 2022, he sold shares in the Company on 27 June and 4 July 2022 while in possession of that inside information; and
- on 6 July 2022, the Company published an unscheduled trading update announcing component supply delays and a reduced deployment forecast. This resulted in the Company’s share price falling sharply.
Having sold his shares in the Company prior to the 6 July 2022 announcement, Mr Dalton avoided a loss of €21,800. His broker submitted a suspicious transaction and order report (“STOR”) to the Central Bank, following which an investigation commenced. Neither the Company nor any of its other employees or agents were the subject of the investigation.
Sanctions
Mr Dalton admitted the contraventions and agreed to settle the matter. The Central Bank imposed:
- disgorgement of €21,800, representing the loss avoided; and
- a monetary sanction of €65,400, equivalent to three times the loss avoided, reduced to €45,780 following a 30% settlement discount.
The total amount payable is €67,580 – the settlement discount does not apply to disgorgement.
In determining the sanctions, the Central Bank considered the deliberate nature of Mr Dalton’s actions, the repetition of the conduct twice within a seven-day period, and the loss avoided. The Statement explains that disgorgement is distinct from a monetary penalty – its purpose is to restore market parity by reversing unjust enrichment, rather than to punish the conduct itself.
Reporting suspicious transactions
Karen O’Leary, Director of Enforcement at the Central Bank, emphasised the importance of timely, high-quality STORs under article 16 of MAR, stating that:
“Firms are responsible for ensuring that they are reporting all reasonable suspicions to the Central Bank.”
In terms of the Central Bank’s investigation of such matters, Ms O’Leary also stated that:
“This outcome demonstrates the Central Bank’s willingness to investigate suspicious transaction and order reports (STORs) received from market intermediaries and follow our investigations through to the appropriate conclusion, holding those engaging in market abuse to account.”
2. Central Bank secures criminal conviction for unauthorised debt management services
On 17 November 2026, the Central Bank of Ireland (“Central Bank”) published a press release (“Press Release”) announced that Ms Rosaleen Grier has been convicted before Longford District Court for providing debt management services without authorisation, in breach of section 29(1) of the Central Bank Act 1997. Ms Grier had previously pleaded guilty to offences relating to services provided between November 2022 and June 2023.
Background
The prosecution followed a Central Bank investigation prompted by a report from the Money Advice and Budgeting Service. An individual had paid Ms Grier over €3,500 for debt management services, but a €20,000 debt write-down she claimed to have negotiated did not materialise.
Outcome
In respect of the first offence, the Court convicted Ms Grier, imposed a €500 fine and ordered a contribution towards the Central Bank’s costs. For the second offence, the Court applied section 1(1) of the Probation of Offenders Act 1907 and ordered payment of €1,200 in compensation to the victim. The Central Bank highlighted its commitment to tackling unauthorised providers and reminded consumers to check its online registers before engaging a financial services firm or adviser.
The Press Release highlights that the prosecution demonstrates the Central Bank’s commitment to protecting consumers by detecting and punishing unauthorised providers of financial services.
1. Central Bank publishes research on motor insurance pricing
On 13 November 2026, the Central Bank of Ireland (“Central Bank”) published research entitled “Understanding Your Motor Insurance Premium” (“Research”), examining the factors influencing motor insurance premiums and consumers’ engagement with the market.
The Research identifies potential savings of around €300 from comparing quotations, with greater potential savings for higher-risk consumers. However, the Central Bank emphasises that price alone does not determine value and that consumers should compare the level and type of cover provided.
Key findings
Some of the matters highlighted by the Research are as follows:
- pricing differences – it is highlighted that insurers assess risk differently and have different cost structures. Differences in quotations may also reflect policy features, including excesses, coverage limits and additional benefits. The quotation exercise covered online new business quotes from eight insurers, representing over 90% of the Irish private motor insurance market, for 16 standardised profiles in June 2026;
- renewal engagement – separate consumer research found that only 9% of surveyed policyholders switched insurer at renewal and one in five renewed without engaging with their insurer. This sits alongside high satisfaction levels, with 78% satisfied with their insurer and 76% happy with how their cover was arranged; and
- distribution channels – online quotations were not available for all profiles, particularly higher-risk consumers. The Central Bank encourages these consumers to contact insurers directly or use a broker, highlighting the continuing importance of channels beyond online quotation services.
Action plan for insurance reform and transparency code
The Research forms part of wider efforts under the Government’s action plan for insurance reform 2025–2029, which sets out 26 actions aimed at improving affordability, transparency, competition and availability in the insurance market – for more information, see FIG Top 5 at 5 dated 31 July 2025.
The Research complements the motor insurance transparency code (“Code”) – for more information see FIG Top 5 at 5 dated 5 March 2026. In its accompanying press release, the Department of Finance confirmed that participating firms have begun introducing the premium summary and market overview statements, with further firms expected to follow over the coming weeks and months.
Government and industry reaction
Welcoming the publication, Minister of State with responsibility for Financial Services, Credit Unions and Insurance, Robert Troy TD, stated:
“Consumers deserve to understand why their premiums have changed and what they can do to secure better value. That is why we are taking steps to improve transparency across the sector, helping motorists better understand their premiums and compare the options available to them.”
Welcoming the Research by way of a press release, Insurance Ireland CEO, Moyagh Murdock, stated:
“We encourage people to compare their options at renewal, but shopping around does not necessarily mean switching. Consumers can speak directly to their existing insurer, seek other quotes online or by phone, or use a broker. The objective should be to find the right combination of price, cover and service.”
2. EIOPA publishes opinion on Commission’s proposed amendments to Solvency II reporting and disclosure ITS
On 12 November 2026, the European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority (“EIOPA”) published an opinion (“Opinion”) on the European Commission’s (“Commission”) proposed amendments to the two sets of draft implementing technical standards (“ITS”) on supervisory reporting and public disclosure under Solvency II.
The Opinion follows EIOPA’s submission of the draft ITS to the Commission on 30 March 2026, as part of its final report on revised supervisory reporting and public disclosure requirements. The proposed revisions reflect the Solvency II review and the Commission’s simplification agenda. For more information, see FIG Top 5 at 5 dated 2 April 2026.
Commission’s proposed amendments
By way of a letter (“Letter”) dated 16 October 2026, the Commission notified EIOPA of its intention to amend the draft ITS by removing the supervisory reporting and public disclosure instructions from the respective ITS. Instead, the Letter explained, the instructions would be made available separately on EIOPA’s website with EIOPA keeping these instructions up to date, taking account of possible input from supervisory authorities and supervised entities.
In the Letter, the Commission explains that this approach is consistent with the approach adopted for banking reporting and disclosure ITS in 2024. It also reflects EIOPA’s revised mandate to develop IT solutions, including reporting and disclosure instructions, to support greater automation and efficiency.
EIOPA’s Opinion
In the Opinion, EIOPA confirms that it does not recommend further amendments to the Commission’s proposals. In particular, EIOPA highlights that:
- the proposed amendments keep both sets of ITS fully aligned with the mandates under articles 35(10) and 56 of the Solvency II Directive;
- publishing the instructions directly on its website will enhance the agility and responsiveness of the reporting and disclosure framework, delivering operational benefits for market participants and supervisory authorities;
- the amendments do not affect the substantive content of its original submission or preparations for technical implementation through the amended taxonomy; and
- the Commission’s additional drafting amendments, aimed at improving readability and clarifying links to the legal mandates, are non-substantive and do not change policy.
Apart from moving instructions to the website, the core substance of EIOPA’s draft ITS – including the proposed reporting reductions and simplifications – remains unchanged as published on 30 March 2026.
Next steps
EIOPA will publish the reporting and disclosure instructions, in English, on its website once the Commission has adopted the two sets of ITS.
EIOPA has confirmed that market participants can continue preparing for the revised Solvency II framework’s entry into application on 30 January 2027, in accordance with the draft ITS on supervisory reporting, the draft ITS on public disclosure and Taxonomy 2.10.0.
1. European Parliament rejects agreement on retail investor protection rules
On 12 November 2026, the European Parliament (“Parliament”) rejected the informal agreement reached with the Council in December 2025 on the proposed directive amending retail investor protection rules, part of the Retail Investment Strategy (“RIS”) package, with 300 votes against, 286 in favour and 23 abstentions.
However, Parliament adopted the accompanying amendments concerning the key information document (“KID”) for packaged retail and insurance-based investment products (“PRIIPs”), concluding its first reading of that proposal.
The procedure regarding the directive on retail investor protection rules will now continue, with a new deadline to be set for tabling amendments before the text will be put to a vote at a subsequent plenary session.
Matheson’s Asset Management and Investment Funds Department has published an insight on this latest development, available here.
2. Matheson to host PSD3 and PSR webinar on 24 November 2026
On 24 November 2026, Matheson will host a webinar entitled “PSD3 and PSR: what changes, what next?”.
Our speakers will explore the EU’s proposed payments reform package, comprising the Third Payment Services Directive (“PSD3”) and the Payment Services Regulation (“PSR”), and what it means for payment service providers and their businesses. The session will combine an overview of the framework with a practical focus on fraud, liability and the steps firms should be considering now.
The webinar will cover:
- the PSD3 / PSR framework: how the two instruments fit together, their scope, and the proposed application timelines and transitional arrangements;
- banks and non-bank payment service providers: the institutional framework, safeguarding and access to payment accounts;
- customer rights: information, consent, payment controls and redress across the payment journey;
- fraud and liability: unauthorised payments, PSP impersonation, verification of payee and transaction monitoring, with practical implications for claims handling, evidence and the roles of technology providers;
- open banking and strong customer authentication: access requirements, consent dashboards and customer control; and
- what comes next: Level 2 technical standards and Level 3 guidance, readiness priorities, and an introduction to Matheson’s PSD3 hub and Level 2 deliverables tracker.
Registration
The webinar will take place on Tuesday, 24 November 2026 from 11:00 am to 12:00 pm – those wishing to attend may register here.

Thought Leadership
Matheson Talks Financial Regulation Podcast
The Matheson Financial Institutions Group are delighted to share with you some useful podcasts.
















