Skip to content

Our Insurance Disputes Practice is a market leader in dealing with the most significant and complex issues facing our clients and the insurance industry in Ireland.

We advise on complex coverage disputes, drafting policy wordings, strategic issues and multi claimant litigation, large loss property damage claims, issues relating to emerging risks such as cyber, subrogation claims, and insurance regulatory litigation.

Matheson has been at the forefront of the most complex and significant coverage issues in Ireland. We are instructed on some of the most significant issues facing the insurance industry and have been involved in many of the landmark cases in this area in recent years.

Our strength and depth is demonstrated by the number of experienced litigators and coverage specialists who work on insurance disputes and coverage issues and our ability to draw on appropriate technical expertise from across the firm.

A number of our lawyers have spent time in-house in the insurance industry. Our lawyers’ risk-management skills and deep sectoral experience also ensure our clients are properly advised in relation to any overlapping internal or regulatory investigation that may arise.

We continue to be one of the few large Irish law firms to have a dedicated Insurance Law Group, and provide a full service to our insurance client base. We provide a comprehensive and seamless service to our clients, and importantly in particular on strategic issues where there is a regulatory aspect.

Experience Highlights

The team has recent experience advising:

  • four of six aircraft lessor plaintiffs in the Aircraft Litigation, relating to insurance coverage for aircraft detained in Russia following the invasion of Ukraine, the largest litigation to come before the Irish courts.
  • a pharmaceutical company in a high value coverage dispute with its D & O insurers, the first judgment of the Irish courts on aggregation in insurance contracts.
  • insurers in two successful test cases to come before the Irish Commercial Court (the only firm to act for insurers in more than one test case).
  • various insurers on COVID-19 business interruption claims and related issues, as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic.
  • an insurer in two separate and successful appeals of findings of the Financial Services & Pensions Ombudsman relating to insurance coverage disputes.
  • an insurer in high profile and precedent setting subrogation claim in relation to flooding in Cork in 2009.
  • a car manufacturer in its defence of various subrogation claims including two lead Commercial Court cases arising from a carpark fire.
  • a major domestic bank in insurance coverage proceedings challenging the declinature of a multi-million dollar claim under its fidelity insurance policy relating to losses arising from the fraudulent trading of an employee in a US subsidiary.
  • a number of insurance companies in relation to implementation of the Consumer Insurance Contracts Act 2019.
  • a London market insurer on the wording for its Irish cyber policy.
  • an international tech company on the wording of various policies, including cyber, written by its captive insurer.
  • a number of financial institutions in relation to their potential exposure and risks of a second redress scheme and multi-party litigation in Ireland, following developments in the UK following the Plevin decision and the FCA’s second redress scheme.

Accolades

“Matheson’s insurance practice have a very wide and deep experience of the insurance industry in Ireland and they apply that experience in a very creative and thorough manner. They will always tell their client what they need to know in a very straightforward and concise manner.”

Insurance: The European Legal 500

2025

Our Team

Angela

Brennan

Partner

Connor

Cassidy

Partner

April

McClements

Partner

Aisling

Kavanagh

Partner

Julie

Murphy-O'Connor

Partner

Karen

Reynolds

Partner

Aishlinn

Gannon

Partner

Darren

Maher

Partner

Gráinne

Callanan

Partner

Our Expertise

Insurance and Reinsurance

© 2025 Matheson LLP | All Rights Reserved